Skip to content

Forum

AI Assistant
Notifications
Clear all

Unpopular opinion: most of us are overcomplicating secret management for simple bots.

17 Posts
17 Users
0 Reactions
5 Views
(@selfhost_raj)
Eminent Member
Joined: 1 week ago
Posts: 20
Translate
English
Spanish
French
German
Italian
Portuguese
Russian
Chinese
Japanese
Korean
Arabic
Hindi
Dutch
Polish
Turkish
Vietnamese
Thai
Swedish
Danish
Finnish
Norwegian
Czech
Hungarian
Romanian
Greek
Hebrew
Indonesian
Malay
Ukrainian
Bulgarian
Croatian
Slovak
Slovenian
Serbian
Lithuanian
Latvian
Estonian
 

Exactly this. The mount point you choose for the read-only file matters more than people think.

If you mount to `/run/secrets` inside the container, that's good. But I've seen folks mount to `/app/.env` or the working directory out of habit. If your app ever gets tricked into a path traversal bug, or you have a stray debug statement that dumps a directory listing, you're giving away the game.

Also, for docker compose users: `secrets:` is your friend for a declarative approach without jumping to Vault. It mounts the file as read-only by default and handles the lifecycle cleanly. It's the perfect middle ground for a homelab stack.

The real cargo cult is thinking every problem needs HashiCorp's solution. Sometimes a locked drawer is enough.


Selfhosted since 2004


   
ReplyQuote
(@cloud_sec_ken)
Active Member
Joined: 1 week ago
Posts: 15
Translate
English
Spanish
French
German
Italian
Portuguese
Russian
Chinese
Japanese
Korean
Arabic
Hindi
Dutch
Polish
Turkish
Vietnamese
Thai
Swedish
Danish
Finnish
Norwegian
Czech
Hungarian
Romanian
Greek
Hebrew
Indonesian
Malay
Ukrainian
Bulgarian
Croatian
Slovak
Slovenian
Serbian
Lithuanian
Latvian
Estonian
 

Timing attacks on a file read? For a bot's secret? That's so deep in the weeds I'd need a GPS. 😄

For that attack to work, you'd need an adversary who can measure the nanosecond differences in your bot's startup, *and* your secret storage has to be so poorly designed that reading one byte is faster than reading a thousand. If you're using a normal file mount, the entire thing gets slurped into the page cache almost instantly.

The real side channel here is logging or error messages. I've seen more secrets leaked because the app logged `Failed to parse key: [REDACTED_BUT_ACTUALLY_THE_FULL_KEY]` than from any timing issue. That's what you should guard against.


- ken


   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 2